What are you looking for?
Ej: Medical degree, admissions, grants...
As a longtime gaming industry observer, I've seen my fair share of disappointing DLC releases, but the latest Shadows expansion hits particularly hard. Having spent over 200 hours across various Assassin's Creed titles, I can confidently say this DLC once again affirms my belief that Shadows should have always exclusively been Naoe's game. The narrative potential was there, but the execution falls painfully short of what fans deserved.
What struck me most was how wooden Naoe and her mother's conversations felt throughout the gameplay. Here we have two characters who haven't seen each other for over a decade - the mother having been captured by Templars while Naoe believed her entire family was dead. Yet when they finally reunite, their interactions lack the emotional depth you'd expect from such a momentous occasion. They hardly speak to one another, and when they do, the dialogue feels like something between casual acquaintances rather than a mother and daughter reconciling after thinking each other were lost forever.
The missed opportunities in character development are staggering. Naoe has nothing to say about how her mom's oath to the Assassin's Brotherhood unintentionally led to her capture for over a decade, leaving Naoe thinking she was completely alone after her father was killed. This should have been the emotional core of the entire DLC - the conflict between duty to the Brotherhood and family obligations. Instead, we get surface-level exchanges that do little to explore these profound themes.
What really frustrated me was the mother's characterization. She evidently has no regrets about not being there for the death of her husband, nor any desire to rekindle anything with her daughter until the last minutes of the DLC. This could have been an interesting character choice if properly explored, but it comes across as poor writing rather than intentional character flaw. The emotional payoff we've been waiting for simply never materializes in a satisfying way.
The final confrontation feels particularly rushed. Naoe spent the final moments of Shadows grappling with the ramifications that her mother was still alive, and then upon meeting her, the two talk like two friends who haven't seen each other in a few years. The lack of emotional intensity in these scenes undermines what should have been the DLC's most powerful moments. And don't even get me started on how Naoe has nothing to say about or to the Templar that kept her mother enslaved so long that everyone assumed she was dead - that's just poor villain utilization.
While the gameplay mechanics remain solid, the narrative shortcomings make this expansion feel like a missed opportunity. The two new major characters, Naoe's mom and the Templar holding her, are written with potential, but the execution fails to deliver the emotional depth the premise promised. It's both surprising and disappointing because the foundation for a compelling family drama was clearly there. As someone who's played through every major Assassin's Creed release since 2007, I can't help but feel this could have been one of the franchise's most memorable storylines with better writing and character development.